Subscribe & Save 5% Storewide + Free Item with Every Order of $175+!

Our Take On The "Impossible Burger"? Would You Eat It?

written by

Liz Cunningham

posted on

August 2, 2019

I feel like I'm in good company here.

Most of you are very informed customers. You do your research and you carefully chose what to feed your family.

The reason that we started selling our meat to people like you is because we are informed people as well and we struggle to find good food for our family.

That's why the "Impossible Burger" is pretty scary to me.If you haven't heard it all over the news, the Impossible Burger is a plant based, meat replacement that apparently tastes and looks exactly like meat. 

Impossible Burger also claims that they use significantly less resources to make their "burger" compared to the conventional beef system. 

My 2 biggest concerns are:

1. The ingredients that they use in the Impossible Burger

2. Is the Impossible Burger really having less of an environmental impact compared to the beef industry?

Let's start with the obvious question everyone always has when a new product hits the marketplace:

1. What ingredients are in the Impossible Burger and what are the possible long-term effects?

The key ingredient in the Impossible Burger is a protein called soy leghemoglobin (SLH), derived from genetically modified (GM) yeast.First red-flag is that most of the burger is comprised of genetically modified materials. Which according to this article by GMO Science that very little if any long-term testing has been done on the safety of Impossible Burger on humans. Not to mention that since GMO soy is the main ingredient in the Impossible Burger it is testing very high for glyphosate residue.No thank you. No "testing" on me or my family.

2. Is the Impossible Burger really having less of an environmental impact compared to the beef industry?The Impossible Burger has put out the claim that they apparently use waaay less water, less greenhouse gas emissions and less aquatic pollutants compared to conventional beef production, but I think they would be hard pressed to really prove their claims in the end. 

If all their ingredients are coming from conventional agriculture farming practices (which is where GMO crops mainly come from) then they are certainly not improving the planet like they claim to be. 

Conventional agriculture is stripping our nation's topsoil and nutrients at an alarming rate and not to mention the health risk potentials as I listed above.

Don't get me wrong, both conventional agriculture and the conventional beef industry are both detrimental to the environment, so I'm not trying to compare the two, but the Impossible Burger would like you to believe that ALL cattle ranchers are responsible for this problem and are causing massive harm to the planet.

This is completely false and gives no credit to those who are making a solid effort to practice regenerative agriculture and seeking to heal the landscape, reduce carbon and improve the health of the land and the water. 

I really like this quote from the Savory Institute in response to the Impossible Burger belittling their work:

"In a world where current agricultural practices have eroded soils to the point of having less than 60 harvests left (according to the UN FAO), the solution is not to maximize efficiencies in the broken, extractive, industrial model. These antiquated systems have no place in a civilization facing the enormous threats of climate change.

Rather, as environmentally-conscious businesses and individuals, we must address the root cause and adopt land management practices that honor the symbiotic relationships of plants and animals. One cannot exist without the other, so we must reevaluate our preconceived notions and return to farming in nature’s image.

Only then will we create a lasting and regenerative agricultural model for a livable planet.

"Boom. That is what we are here to do. 

So the final question is... Would you eat an Impossible Burger? 

I think you know what my answer is...

P.S. You might be wondering: "Do you believe that the Impossible Burger could affect the cattle industry?"

Yes, I believe that if the Impossible Burger does grow in popularity over time that there will be an affect on cattle prices and demand. However, that falls much further down my line of concerns than what I have listed above. I fear for people's health and the health of the land more than whether the Impossible Burger is going to impact the cattle industry long-term.

Impossible Burger

Burger

Beef

GMO

Genetically Modified

Cattle Industry

More from the blog

Bird Flu Explained

Ask anyone who buys eggs regularly at the grocery store, and you'll be met with the question.Why are egg prices so high?!Basic conventional raised eggs at the grocery store have reached record-high prices, and most stores are limiting the number of eggs people can purchase.There is clearly a supply and demand issue at the moment, but what is causing such an egg shortage?This might surprise some of you, but the egg shortage is directly correlated with the governments policy of handling the outbreak of the avian bird flu.Bird flu isn't new; it has been present worldwide since the early 2000s, yet it has recently gained renewed attention.The United States Department of Agriculture's (USDA) policy regarding bird flu states that if your flock tests positive for the virus, all poultry on that farm will be "depopulated" (a euphemism for being killed). This means that if one bird shows signs of illness or dies and the USDA confirms it as bird flu, they will eliminate the entire flock of chickens or turkeys on the farm. The testing method used for bird flu is the PCR test, which gained notoriety during the COVID outbreak for its false positives.This isn't speculation. We witnessed this firsthand with our friends this fall when their turkey flock became sick and died. The USDA came and tested, confirming that it was indeed bird flu. They didn't have to kill any turkeys because their flock succumbed to the virus quickly. However, their small group of laying hens, which they kept for personal egg consumption and were healthy despite being exposed to the turkeys, had to be killed if they wanted any compensation from the USDA.Large confinement operations can house up to 250,000 chickens. Many of these farms have multiple houses, so if a large operation is confirmed to have bird flu, it is required to cull all the chickens on the farm; sometimes, this number well exceeds 250,000. In the last two years, over 160 million chickens and turkeys have been killed to "slow the spread." Yet, bird flu continues to spread.The USDA blames wild birds for carrying and transmitting the disease, yet I have yet to hear the USDA consider a widespread extermination plan for wild birds like starlings, pigeons, and chickadees, but only for the farmers who have chickens and turkeys?For a chicken to start laying eggs, they must be at least 5 months old before they begin to lay regularly. So if a laying operation has to depopulate their entire farm, they will have a minimum of 5 months before they have eggs again, and that's IF they can find chicks to restock their farm.   There has been no discussion about breeding chickens that have contracted bird flu but survived the disease. What happened to the survival of the fittest?With millions of chickens being exterminated from the food supply, it's no wonder that egg prices are skyrocketing!   Unless the USDA policy changes, it's unlikely we'll see a significant drop in egg prices, unless many new farmers enter the market willing to raise and sell eggs.  In the meantime, we will continue to supply our customers with our small flock of laying hens that my daughter raises. 

Our Favorite Winter Activity ⛸️

Each winter, when the creeks on our ranch freeze over, our kids rush out to check if the ice is thick enough for skating. Once it is, they spend hours on the ice, knowing the cold may not last. This year, we enjoyed nearly a week of perfect skating, though it got crowded with six kids on the creek. Our younger ones joined in, being pulled in a sled by their older siblings. After hours of skating and plenty of laughs, warmer temperatures ended the season, leaving behind great memories.

"Oops Calves" In The Freezing Winter

This week, we had some surprise early calves after a bull escaped his pasture. Normally, we don’t start calving until March, but these early arrivals faced challenges with the cold, wet weather. While most did well, one calf struggled to stay warm and had to be brought inside to warm up. After some time, we sent him back to mom for a good nursing. This experience has reminded us to check our fences and keep a better count of our bulls next spring!

Boise's #1 source for 100% Grassfed beef & lamb, pastured pork & chicken and wild-caught seafood